Classic vs preppy: How can I even compare these two? I thought. As I got into deeper analysis, there were surprisingly many similarities. So, what is classic vs preppy?
As a general rule, both styles convey a sense of timeless elegance and uniqueness. Nevertheless, there are some differences. While the preppy style leans towards vibrant and colorful apparel, the classic style is characterized by its neutral hues and versatile garments, akin to the refined aesthetics of old money.
There are lots of other differences and similarities between those two we will discuss in this article in full detail. Also, we will look at their history to determine if there is a similar origin.
Origins of preppy and classic
We will start with a little definition of each style first, to create a better understanding.
Classic style:
The classic style empathizes with timeless elegance and sophistication. It expresses mostly through classic silhouettes, minimalistic approaches, and high-quality, tailored clothes. Its origin lies in the early 20th century as a follow-up to mass-produced, well-cut suits. It isn’t tied to a specific subculture or style though.
Preppy style:
‘Preppy’ originates from the expression ‘Preparatory school’ and was first used in the 1950s in America. The upper middle-and upper-class children attended these university-preparatory schools. It describes the combination of classic items combined with sporty clothing. This creates a youthful but timeless and elegant vibe.
As you may see, both styles have a similar time of origin but are generally different in their history. Even though, both embody the timeless and elegant vibe, you can sense major differences let alone their choice of colors. So, let’s jump in and discuss how these differences come to play but also which similarities there might be.
Classic vs preppy, differences and similarities
For similarities you can say that there are a lot. This list will contain the most impacting ones to not be overloaded with information:
- Timeless elegance and versatility: Both styles feature timelessness and versatility through their simple but elegant designs.
- Clean lines and classic silhouettes: The favor of clean lines combined with classic silhouettes is a perfect match for the classic and preppy style. The clothes may flatter the body without being overly revealing.
- Quality over quantity: Whether it’s a well-tailored blazer in the classic style or a pair of high-quality loafers in the preppy style, both emphasize investing in well-made, durable pieces. This is a general rule for any style featured in this blog.
- Neutral colors: While preppy uses brighter colors too, both styles tend to stick to a neutral color scheme for most times.
- Casual and formal appeal: Both styles can be adapted to different settings and occasions. They can transition seamlessly from casual to formal events with the right mix of garments and accessories.
- Attention to detail: Lastly, you will see that whoever wears this style correctly, lays a focus on details. No wrinkles or stains may be found on classic and preppy clothing.
Whilst these similarities may give you a perception of total accordance, there are still distinct differences between those two.
| Classic style | Preppy style |
|---|---|
| Draws inspiration from various styles | Didn’t draw attention from styles but emerges in collegiate circumstances |
| Subtle to no patterns | Patterns such as stripes gingham, or plaid |
| Minimalistic accessories (watches, leather belts) | Showcases accessories (colourful scarves, statement belts) |
| Prioritizes simplicity | Embodies youthful aesthetic |
| More formal and elegant attire | Mostly combination of classic and sporty |
Classic vs preppy clothing
As we’ve now discussed the similarities and differences between the classic vs preppy style, we will now look at clothes to define each style. Both preppy and classic styles boast a rich array of garments, including:
- Button-down shirts
- Polo shirts
- Blazers
- Cable-knit sweaters
- Cardigans
- Little black dresses
- Striped shirts
- Chinos
- Tailored pants
- A-line skirts
- Trench coats
This wide variety of clothes shows that there are many clothes both styles contain. Now, let’s look at some shoes:
- Loafers
- Boat shoes
- Oxford shoes
- Pumps
These items might lead one to assume a sameness in appearance. However, the fine distinction to create different outfits with similar clothes lies in the choice of colors, patterns, layering, and cut. But there are also different clothes we will discuss now:
Preppy:
Preppy’s casual and youthful lifestyle leads to some clothes classic would never wear. Pleated skirts or argyle sweaters are just two of those items. Due to their coastline life in the USA, seersucker blazers and madras shirts are also typical preppy clothes.
Classic:
The rather formal attire of the classic style and some variations of classic styles lead to formal suits and tailored trench coats being classic items preppy doesn’t wear. Also, shift dresses and turtleneck sweaters are common classic garments you will not find in preppy style.
If you want to find out more about all the different types of classic styles, check out my article about 5 of them here.
Classic vs preppy outfits
In this section, we will compare the three most popular outfits from each style to see where the differences are and where we may find some similarities.
Preppy outfits
The casual preppy outfit:
One of the three most renowned outfits of preppy has to be a casual one with a polo shirt. Additionally, you may wear a pair of chinos or khaki pants as well as some loafers. This outfit will work for men and women in the same way. Consider a watch or bracelet as an accessory to complete the look.
The formal preppy outfit for women:
Comin’ to a formal outfit, the hallmark plaid pattern takes center stage. You will want to wear a plaid skirt for this formal preppy outfit. In addition, you can add a matching blazer. Underneath, pick a neutral-colored top that matches the colors of the outerwear.
For shoes, pumps or flats will be great. Enhance the ensemble with a bracelet, necklace, and sunglasses.
‘Formal’ preppy outfit for men
You may wonder about the quotation marks around ‘formal.’ Personally, I don’t think this outfit truly is a formal one but rather a combination of casual and formal. This preppy outfit for men is one of preppy that you may confuse with the classic style.
The combination of either a polo or button-down shirt layered with a sweater is known for both classic and preppy aesthetics. For pants, you may use chinos or tailored pants. If worn preppy, you can add a J. Crew jacket or make it look like a school uniform.
Classic outfits
The casual classic outfit for women:
Echoing the carefree spirit often attributed to preppy style, the classic aesthetic can also channel casual summer vibes.
For this outfit, you will need a white top or polo shirt. Now, you can add some light-colored shorts or a skirt to create a great casual but elegant look. Additionally, you may throw over a linen shirt. For shoes, choose sandals, and as accessories, a straw hat, a bracelet or necklace, and sunglasses.
For further insights into classic summer outfits, explore my dedicated article on the topic here.
Casual classic outfit for men:
Between all those casual classic outfits, this one may look a little preppy. For this outfit, you will need a polo shirt or T-shirt in a neutral color as a base layer. For pants, choose chinos or khaki pants. Additionally, you may layer this outfit with a neutral-colored, mostly navy or black blazer.
For shoes, pick elegant sneakers or loafers. As accessories, wear a watch and a belt.
Formal classic outfit for him and her
The quintessential classic suit is the cornerstone of this formal attire for men. Optimally, you will want to wear a black or navy suit with a white dress shirt underneath. Choose Oxford shoes and add a belt and watch as accessories.
The woman may either match this aesthetic with her own suit and similar accessories, or a bracelet. Otherwise, she may choose a long and elegant plain dress in a neutral color. She will want to wear heels or pumps for this formal attire. Earrings are great add-ons.
Classic vs preppy aesthetic and lifestyle
This is the part where you can see big differences between classic vs preppy. As evident from their clothing choices, preppy enthusiasts tend to be more youthful and outgoing. Their lifestyle embraces parties and recreational pursuits like tennis and golf.
Classic style seeks more cultural-based activities like traveling to cultural places or visiting museums. When it comes to professions, the preppy style focuses on law, medicine, or finances whereas the classic doesn’t have a particular type. Needless to say, they both strive for success in their professions.
Generally, you can sense a lot more outgoing and socializing with the preppy style compared to rather old money-like behavior from the classic style. Nevertheless, both aesthetics have their place and represent elegance.
Summary
As you can see from this article, classic vs preppy styles have some things in common regarding their clothing. Nevertheless, their history is rather different and you may find rather big differences in their lifestyle.
Even though some outfits may get mixed up, they are elegant and sophisticated styles on their own.